National Army Museum logo
Visit the National Army Museum Shop
view counter

Enemy Commanders: Britain's Greatest FoesEnemy Commanders: Britain's Greatest Foes

5 comments

Gary Wright
2 March 2012, 3.24pm

I would have suggested De Wet

I would have suggested De Wet but that would split the vote between him and Botha so Botha get's my wholehearted vote.

Peter Lague
12 March 2012, 10.48am

Considering that the Boers

Considering that the Boers were basically farmers and outnumbered 5 to 1 against professionals he caused considerable losses to the British forces using at that time unconventional methods that the British were slow to learn from. In the end the Boers lost by an unconventional method, not military.

What no Smuts?
12 March 2012, 5.36pm

I rather fancied J.C. Smuts

I rather fancied J.C. Smuts (who made the Britain's Greatest General shortlist last year) making a reappearance in this year's Britain’s Greatest Foe / Enemy Commander list. That said, when he assumed his military command during the Boer War Smuts styled himself as "Assistant Comdt.-General" to Commandant-General Botha - thus arguably crediting his own commando's successes to his superior, Louis Botha, despite being cut off from his chain of command.

Maritz Spaarwater
18 March 2012, 4.42pm

My vote goes to Louis Botha

My vote goes to Louis Botha because my grandfather and his brother both fought under him, and because he put up his tremendous performance against the Brits before he became an imperialist himself.

Chris Raats
20 March 2012, 3.27pm

Reading all accounts by

Reading all accounts by Brittisch commanders and soldiers, Botha was the most formidable commander faceing the Brits. Also, reports between Britton and the comanders in SA, it was clear the Boers under Botha gave them serious uphill. Only after adding thousands of additional soldiers and applying the scorched earth and concentration camp strategy did they gain upperhand.

Add your comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.

(By ticking this box you agree for your name and email address to be added to the National Army Museum's mailing list. You also accept the terms of the National Army Museum's Privacy Policy)

Please note: By submitting a comment you are agreeing to the terms laid out in the National Army Museum's Rules for User Comments. Any views expressed in user comments do not necessarily reflect or represent the views of the National Army Museum or its staff.