National Army Museum logo
Find out more about Venue Hire at the National Army Museum
view counter

Britain's Greatest GeneralBritain's Greatest General

16 comments

RCooper
19 January 2011, 1.27pm

Achieved complete victory out

Achieved complete victory out of nothing in appaling conditions.

Tom Green
20 January 2011, 1.52am

Any general can have victory

Any general can have victory from success; Slim teased success out from failure.

Phil Mc Carty
20 January 2011, 11.01am

The complete package.

The complete package. Strategist, tactician, leader. The telling fact was his reinstatement after Lees' petulant attempt to sack him.

Jim Carr
20 January 2011, 12.46pm

Simply brilliant as a soldier

Simply brilliant as a soldier and a general

Rob McNaught
20 January 2011, 2.56pm

The master of creating

The master of creating something from nothing.

Chris Johnson
25 January 2011, 5.43pm

Uncle Bill..... the soldier's

Uncle Bill..... the soldier's soldier.

Jeremy Havard
26 January 2011, 4.41am

Or them all, the most

Or them all, the most original and resourceful, who thought on his feet and won his battles and the whole campaign by turning the enemy's methods upon themselves. His cool and objective analysis in the fog of war, heat of battle and pressure of inherited defeat place him head and shoulders above any of the others. Wellington, Marlborough, Moore were all truly great generals, as were others on this list, but they fought on their own terms and reacted differently to reverses. Slim, on the other hand, outh-thought the enemy who used strategies and tactics which the British had never before encountered. He was in completely uncharted territory and simply used his strategic and tactical training/thinking at a higher level than any of the others on this list were ever called upon to do. No question about who is the greatest on this list. you should all read up on him!

Michael Cornwell
26 January 2011, 10.40am

He achieved so much in a

He achieved so much in a Theatre of War that was not in the nation's forethoughts at the time and lacked the resources of other Theatres. This shows the quality of his qualities in a true light.

David Lawrence
26 January 2011, 9.06pm

A great soldier & master of

A great soldier & master of the battlefield.

Raymond Callahan
5 February 2011, 6.23pm

The greatness of a general is

The greatness of a general is a matter both of his character and what he did in the the circumstances he faced with the resources he had. On both counts,Slim qualifies as the best British field commander of world War II--and the best general the English-speaking world produced in the Twentieth Century.

Jack Taylor
14 February 2011, 3.10pm

He led his army against a

He led his army against a fearsome enemy with consummate skill and improvisation. He had not a fraction of the equipment available to the army in Europe and with an attitude of "make do & mend" he almost completely annihilated a couple of Japanese armies. Additionally he was well loved by his men who were from every continent of the globe.

Andy Pozniak
18 February 2011, 9.09am

The master of the twentieth

The master of the twentieth century battlefield.No general did so much with so little.To paraphrase Duncan Anderson: Slim was a general of administrative genius,a brilliant defensive general and the equal of
Guderian ,Manstein and Patton as an offensive commander.If he does not win it will be a travesty.

Jerry Bird
19 March 2011, 5.36pm

Commanding General Officer of

Commanding General Officer of the 14th 'Forgotten' Army - Forgotten General? The name of Bill Slim does not normally rank alongside other WWII Allied Generals when people think of the more well known figures in the 'Western' theater of operations - the Montgomery's, Bradley's, Wavell's, Patton's and of course Eisenhower himself. Even US General McArthur is probably better known for his exploits in the Pacific than Bill Slim in Burma.

Like most aspects of the Burma Campaign, Bill Slim was/is relatively unknown in the broader context of WWII, but to those who served under him his inspired leadership was truly remembered, especially as it was through that leadership the tide of war in Burma turned against the Japanese.

Would things have been different in 1942 if Bill Slim had been in charge then? Maybe not, but when he was given command he pulled together what forces he had, built them up into a formidable fighting army which carried the fight to the Japanese right through to the cessation of hostilities. This happened within a period of only two years against an enemy who were still very much on the offensive and far from defeated, as compared to the 4 years between Dunkirk and Normandy in Europe.

Yes, the other Generals are all praiseworthy for their remarkable exploits, but then they were much more in the public eye, and their names more readily known. Bill Slim deserves the recognition as Britain's Greatest General.

Anonymous
3 April 2011, 3.29am

Mr. Bird's assessment is

Mr. Bird's assessment is spot-on; day-in and day-out, Field Marshal Slim did more with less under the most primitive of conditions in Burma than any other commander in any other theater. Given his understanding of strategy, tactics, logistics and air-mindedness, there is no doubt that if he had been in charge in France in 1944, Arnhem would NOT have been a bridge too far and the Allies would have been in Berlin by Christmas.

Ed Purvis
3 May 2011, 2.44pm

I read Ronald Lewin's book

I read Ronald Lewin's book Slim : The Standard Bearer when I was younger, and then Bill Slim's own book Defeat into Victory and as a result I have always regarded him as the outstanding commander of WW2. I am very satisfied with the result.

Ian Neve
17 May 2011, 2.29pm

My late father served under

My late father served under him in Abyssinia and Iraq and would have approved of this choice.

Add your comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.

(By ticking this box you agree for your name and email address to be added to the National Army Museum's mailing list. You also accept the terms of the National Army Museum's Privacy Policy)

Please note: By submitting a comment you are agreeing to the terms laid out in the National Army Museum's Rules for User Comments. Any views expressed in user comments do not necessarily reflect or represent the views of the National Army Museum or its staff.